When we asked ChatGPT 3.5 to "write Python code to count the number of crossings and nestings of an arc diagram on 2n points labelled by 0 to 2n-1 on the line" (we had to add the labelling instruction to get the indexing right), it produced the following answer. Sure, an arc diagram represents pairwise relationships between points. Here's a Python code snippet using a simple approach to count the number of crossings and nestings in an arc diagram on 2n points: def count crossings_and_nestings(arcs): n = len(arcs) // 2 crossings = 0 nestings = 0 for i in range(2 * n): for j in range(i + 1, 2 n): if arcs [i] [0] < arcs [j] [0] < arcs [i] [1] < arcs [j] [1]: crossings += 1 elif arcs [i] [0] > arcs [j] [0] > arcs [i] [1] > arcs [j] [1]: crossings += 1 elif arcs [i][0] < arcs [j] [0] < arcs [j] [1] < arcs [i] [1]: nestings += 1 elif arcs [i] [0] > arcs [j] [0] > arcs [i] [1] > arcs [j] [1]: nestings += 1 return crossings, nestings # Example usage: n = 4 # You can change this to the desired number of points (2n points) arcs [(0, 3), (1, 2), (4, 7), (5, 6), (8, 11), (9, 10), (12, 15), (13, 14)] crossings, nestings = count_crossings_and_nestings(arcs) print (f"Number of crossings: {crossings}") print("Number of nestings: (nestings)") This code defines a function count_crossings_and_nestings that takes a list of arcs as input, where each arc is represented as a tuple (start, end). The function then iterates through all pairs of arcs and checks for crossings and nestings based on their start and end points. The example usage shows how to use the function with a sample set of arcs. You can modify the arcs variable with your specific arc diagram data for testing.
From the example suggested, this is the output I get if we run the code:
n = 4
arcs = [(0, 3), (1, 2), (4, 7), (5, 6), (8, 11), (9, 10), (12, 15), (13, 14)]
crossings, nestings = count_crossings_and_nestings(arcs)
print(f"Number of crossings: {crossings}")
print(f"Number of nestings: {nestings}")
However, upon closer inspection of the code, the function is not working as expected because there's an issue with the logic: the condition checks for nestings are repeated.
It should be checking for one case where the start of one arc is between the start and end of another arc, and the end of one arc is between the start and end of another arc. The same condition is used twice in the code.
And I tried computing nestings and crossings with the smallest examples below:
def count_crossings_and_nestings(arcs):
n = len(arcs) // 2
crossings = 0
nestings = 0
for i in range(2 * n):
for j in range(i + 1, 2 * n):
if arcs[i][0] < arcs[j][0] < arcs[i][1] < arcs[j][1]:
crossings += 1
elif arcs[i][0] > arcs[j][0] > arcs[i][1] > arcs[j][1]:
crossings += 1
elif arcs[i][0] < arcs[j][0] < arcs[j][1] < arcs[i][1]:
nestings += 1
elif arcs[i][0] > arcs[j][0] > arcs[i][1] > arcs[j][1]:
nestings += 1
return crossings, nestings
#Test cases
test_cases=[
[], # Empty set of arcs
[(0,1)], # Single arc
[(0,1),(2,3)], # Two non-overlapping arcs
[(0,3),(1,2)], # Two overlapping arcs
[(0,2),(1,3)] # Two nested arcs
]
for i, arcs in enumerate(test_cases，1):
crossings, nestings = count_crossings_and_nestings(arcs)
print(f"Test case {i}:")
print(f"Number of arcs: {len(arcs)}")
print(f"Number of crossings: {crossings}")
print(f"Number of nestings: {nestings}")
print()
Explanation below:
{} (empty set of arcs): The output can be defined as (0, 0).
{(0, 1)} (single arc): The output can be defined as (0, 0) because there are no crossings or nestings.
{(0, 1), (2, 3)} (two non-overlapping arcs): The output can be defined as (0, 0) because there are no crossings or nestings.
{(0, 3), (1, 2)} (two overlapping arcs): The output can be defined as (1, 0) because there is one crossing but no nestings.
{(0, 2), (1, 3)} (two nested arcs): The output can be defined as (0, 1) because there are no crossings but one nesting.
The output matches the expectations for all the test cases. Therefore, the function is working.
My question needed from you is:
For diagrams with three arcs, there are 15 possibilities. Find one for which the function count_crossings_and_nestings provides a wrong result. Print the result and draw the corresponding diagram.
![When we asked ChatGPT 3.5 to "write Python code to count the number of crossings and nestings of an arc diagram on 2n points labelled by 0 to 2n-1 on the line" (we
had to add the labelling instruction to get the indexing right), it produced the following answer.
Sure, an arc diagram represents pairwise relationships between points. Here's a Python code snippet using a simple approach to count the number of
crossings and nestings in an arc diagram on 2n points:
def count_crossings_and_nestings(arcs):
n = len(arcs) // 2
crossings = 0
nestings = 0
for i in range(2 * n):
for j in range(i + 1, 2 * n):
if arcs[i] [0] < arcs[j][0] < arcs[i] [1] < arcs [j] [1]:
crossings += 1
elif arcs [i] [0] > arcs [j] [0] > arcs [i] [1] > arcs [j] [1] :
crossings += 1
elif arcs [i] [0] < arcs [j] [0] < arcs [j] [1] < arcs [i] [1]:
nestings += 1
elif arcs [i] [0] > arcs [j] [0] > arcs[i] [1] > arcs[j] [1]:
nestings += 1
return crossings, nestings
# Example usage:
n = 4
# You can change this to the desired number of points (2n points)
arcs = [(0, 3), (1, 2), (4, 7), (5, 6), (8, 11), (9, 10), (12, 15), (13, 14)]
crossings, nestings = count_crossings_and_nestings(arcs)
print (f"Number of crossings: {crossings}")
print (f"Number of nestings: {nestings}")
This code defines a function count_crossings_and_nestings that takes a list of arcs as input, where each arc is represented as a tuple (start, end).
The function then iterates through all pairs of arcs and checks for crossings and nestings based on their start and end points. The example usage shows
how to use the function with a sample set of arcs.
You can modify the arcs variable with your specific arc diagram data for testing.](/v2/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fcontent.bartleby.com%2Fqna-images%2Fquestion%2F033c0d82-90fb-4c58-9b03-1325bfffdb8d%2Fe7df7b8e-31eb-4954-947f-802e37f16af7%2F1vhbkmf_processed.png&w=3840&q=75)
Trending now
This is a popular solution!
Step by step
Solved in 4 steps with 4 images
